I just got an e-mail from Pony Club about the high number of eventing deaths in the last year. Pony Club was calling for all leaders and participants to make sure that members are competing at the appropriate level.
They cited the following story, which I will excerpt here, from the New York Times:
A failed jump by one of the world’s finest riders and a spate of deaths have unnerved the equestrian community.
Darren Chiacchia, 43, who helped the United States Olympic team win
a bronze medal at the Athens Games and was considered a favorite for
this year’s team, was training a horse on an intermediate course in
Tallahassee, Fla., last month when the stallion crashed over a fence,
crushing — and nearly killing — its celebrated rider.
Mr. Chiacchia spent a week in a coma and is now recovering at a
rehabilitation facility near his home in Buffalo. Meanwhile, the sport
he devoted his life to faces an identity crisis. Considered alongside
the deaths of 12 riders worldwide over the past year and a half, his
crash has reignited a fierce debate over whether the risks involved
with the equestrian discipline known as eventing — an arduous
three-phase competition — have become too great......
An Olympic sport since 1912, eventing originated as a way to test
the ability and endurance of military horses. It is often called a
horse triathlon because participants compete in three events over one-,
two- or three-day competitions: the delicate footwork of dressage, the
beauty and control of show jumping, and the endurance and daring of
cross-country racing. The winding courses of up to two and a half miles
are designed to mimic the natural obstacles of rural landscapes.
“It’s considered by many to be the ultimate test of horse and rider,” Mr. Baumgardner said.
The cross-country phase is the most dangerous, as horse and rider
are required to clear 20 to 40 jumps in an established time period.
Penalties are assessed if the horse balks at a jump, if the horse or
rider falls, or if their time is too slow. Riders look for courage and
well-roundedness in eventing horses, which can cost anywhere from
$25,000 to $1 million each.
All 12 of the recent deaths occurred during the cross-country phase
as riders attempted to clear obstacles, including some that were
startlingly simple. Most of the deaths resulted from what are called
rotational falls, somersaulting flips similar to Mr. Chiacchia’s.....
.....amateur riders say that lower-level courses have also become more
difficult in order to prepare aspiring riders for the next level. (emphasis mine)
“It’s not galloping cross-country over natural obstacles anymore,”
said Ilana Gareen, an amateur rider and assistant professor of
community health at Brown. “I liked the fact that you could go to
eventing and just be a good rider, do well, and have fun.”
I left out a lot and there's more that follows. I haven't kept up with eventing since I quit doing my low-level but fun rides when work got too demanding -- and eventing had become impossible on another level.
I knocked myself out to compete in eventing. My employers let me work on flex time during the season so that I could come in early and leave work before it was too dark to ride. I took my vacation days to trailer to events and stayed in hotels worse than the stable my horse was in. (One motel had bullet holes in the door, I'm sure of it.) It was exhausting. It took lots of money. It was excellent fun and absolutely thrilling. I even got to cover the events I went to as a reporter for The Chronicle of the Horse. (I never competed at the top levels so there was no conflict -- I would not be interviewing or covering the stories about people at my level.)
But it began to dawn on me that some people competing at my level were not at all at my level. Many were professionals, and I remember at one event that there was a former Olympian competing a young horse at my level. I was usually put in divisions with professional riders, teachers, trainers and even my own coaches -- not because of any handicapping system or because I was good, which I wasn't. Amateurs and professionals were routinely mixed up.
I don't need to win, but I need to feel like I have a chance. It was discouraging. So I wrote an opinion piece for The Chronicle of the Horse expressing my frustration. What I proposed were amateur and professional divisions. I found out that's a great way to get a lot of people mad at you.
The local and regional professionals don't want to be in a class with national and international stars. But what fun is it to beat people like me? That was a long time ago, and some of these folks still hold a grudge. I'm no longer a member of any of the organizations so I don't know for sure that things haven't changed, but a search online of entry forms and other eventing information doesn't seem to show that anything has been divided into amateur and professional divisions.
I think that what I complained about may be in part what is behind these deaths, especially when the falls are attributed to inexperienced or amateur riders who aren't as good as the professionals they're competing against.
Well, DUH! Here's some more from the NYT's article:
Top competitors, coaches and course designers argue that the sport’s
death and injury toll is most likely related to an influx of new riders
to the sport. Participation in eventing competitions in the United
States has grown by 36 percent over the past decade; riders filled
roughly 46,000 competition slots in 2007, according to the association.
“You have people who didn’t grow up fox hunting or going on wild
rides the way we did,” said Mick Costello, an event rider who builds
cross-country courses. “They haven’t been used to tumbling falls. They
get a thrill out of going fast, and a lot of them aren’t ready.”
Mr. Costello and others acknowledge that the increasing skill of top
riders has pushed them to create more complex courses. They have
recently been designing “speed bumps” to slow the riders, to little
avail. “These people are so good, they just take it in stride,” he said.
I'm sorry. I grew up foxhunting and racing my friends on dirt roads. We did wild, crazy things and lived to tell about it. That doesn't make me Olympic material or prepared for courses designed to challenge the professionals. They've taken out the fun and replaced it with unacceptable risk.
And by the way. You can have a good, fun event horse for under $25,000. In fact, you can remove a zero and still get something sound and fun. You won't beat the Olympians, but you probably wouldn't beat them if you spent $100,000. Not that I'd know.